top of page

Text 715-338-6111

The Most Delicious Part of Your Deer… Besides the Backstraps? The Heart!

Writer: Six Peaks Quality Meats
Six Peaks Quality Meats
5 days ago
3 min read

Backstraps get all the attention. And trust us—we understand why. But there’s another part of your deer that deserves a spot in the frying pan: the heart.

If you’ve been leaving it behind in the woods, you might be missing out on a new deer-season favorite.

In our family, deer heart has been a prized part of the harvest for years. Our oldest daughter loved it so much when she was little that everyone knew to save theirs for her. Grandparents, aunts, uncles—if someone got a deer, she had dibs on the heart.

At one point, we had a fridge full of deer hearts. Most kids request chicken nuggets. Ours request deer heart!

But here’s the key: how you trim it, slice it, and cook it makes all the difference.


Start with a Good Trim

The heart is a hardworking muscle. Properly trimmed and sliced, it makes a delicious skillet meal without a complicated recipe.

Start with a clean and chilled deer heart and a sharp knife.

  1. Trim the outside. Remove the firm fat around the top, along with the large blood vessels and any tough outer connective tissue.

  2. Open the heart. Cut lengthwise through the chambers so you can see the inside and lay the meat open.

  3. Remove the tough parts. Trim away the valves, stringy cords, and firm, pale connective tissue—the chewy pieces of cartilage. Leave the clean muscle.

  4. Pat dry and slice. Cut across the grain into even slices about ¼ inch thick. Similar-sized slices cook more evenly, and a dry surface helps them brown.

Taking a few extra minutes here makes a big difference once it hits the pan.


Our Family’s Cast-Iron Deer Heart with Butter and Onions

No fancy marinade. No long ingredient list. Just butter, onions, garlic and a good cast-iron pan.

Ingredients

  • 1 deer heart, cleaned, trimmed, and thinly sliced

  • 1 stick butter (½ cup)

  • 1 large onion, sliced into rings

  • 1-2 Tbsp minced garlic

  • Salt and pepper, to taste

  • Or Brandon’s favorite: Nature’s Seasons seasoning blend

Directions

1. Melt the butter

Place a large cast-iron skillet over medium heat and add one stick of butter. Let it melt without burning.

2. Add the onion "rings" and minced garlic

Separate the sliced onion into rings and add them and the minced garlic to the butter. Cook, stirring occasionally, until softened and beginning to turn golden.

By this point, the kitchen should smell like someone made a very good decision.

3. Make room for the heart

Move the onions toward the outside of the skillet. Add the heart slices to the middle in a single layer so each piece touches the pan. Work in batches if needed.

4. Season it up

Sprinkle with salt and pepper, or use Brandon’s go-to, Nature’s Seasons. If using the seasoning blend, taste before adding any extra salt.

5. Cook, flip, and finish

Let the slices brown, then flip to cook the other side. Thin slices cook quickly, so stay close to the skillet. For food safety, cook venison to 160°F, checking with an instant-read thermometer inserted sideways into the thickest slice. Remove promptly once it reaches temperature to avoid unnecessary extra cooking.

6. Bring it all together

Move the onions back into the center, toss them with the heart slices, and spoon that buttery goodness over everything. Serve hot, with plenty of onions on every plate.


Give the Heart a Place at Your Table

Wisconsin deer season is full of traditions: opening-morning anticipation, stories from the stand, and meals shared with the people who understand why we get up so early to sit in the cold.

For our family, a pan of deer heart with butter and onions is part of that tradition.

At Six Peaks – Quality Meats, we appreciate making the most of a hard-earned harvest. The backstraps may get claimed first, but give the heart a try—you might find yourself with a kid who starts collecting them from the whole family, too.

Save the heart. Slice the onions. Grab the cast iron.


Field-to-kitchen note: Keep the heart clean and chill it promptly. Skip hearts damaged by a bullet or potentially contaminated with lead fragments; UW–Madison Extension specifically cautions about lead in organs from heart-lung shots.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page